← All insights
INSIGHTS ON STUTTERING

Stuttering and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) is a psychological approach developed by Steven C. Hayes and colleagues. Rather than focusing primarily on eliminating unwanted thoughts and emotions, ACT aims to develop psychological flexibility: the ability to remain open to one’s experiences while engaging in actions guided by personal values.

ACT is built around six interconnected processes: acceptance, cognitive defusion, present-moment awareness, self-as-context, values, and committed action. Together, these processes encourage individuals to change their relationship with difficult thoughts and feelings rather than becoming caught in attempts to control or avoid them.

For people who stutter, ACT may involve developing a greater willingness to experience anxiety, embarrassment, or uncertainty while continuing to participate in meaningful communication. The goal is not necessarily to reduce stuttering or eliminate discomfort, but to ensure that these experiences do not unnecessarily restrict how a person chooses to live.

Stuttering

Understanding Stuttering

Stuttering is a neurodevelopmental condition characterized by disruptions in the flow of speech, such as repetitions, prolongations, and blocks. However, the experience of stuttering extends far beyond its observable characteristics.

For many people who stutter, the experience also involves anticipation, anxiety, shame, and efforts to avoid or conceal stuttering. These experiences can influence communication, social participation, and quality of life. Importantly, stuttering is highly variable, and its frequency and severity cannot be reliably controlled through effort alone.

Understanding stuttering therefore requires attention not only to speech itself, but also to how individuals experience stuttering, respond to it, and navigate their everyday lives.

ACT in Stuttering Therapy

Among the earliest researchers to explore the application of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) to stuttering were Beilby and Yarus (2012) 1 Their pioneering study investigated an integrated intervention combining ACT principles with fluency-focused treatment for 20 adults who stutter. The researchers reported improvements in psychosocial functioning, psychological flexibility, and speech fluency, although the study was limited by its small sample size and lack of a control group.

Subsequent approaches have continued to integrate ACT principles with speech-focused interventions. One example is fACTS (Fluency and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for Stuttering) 2, which combines acceptance- and values-based processes with fluency-oriented treatment. Another is Multidimensional Individualized Stuttering Therapy (MIST), developed by Sønsterud and colleagues (2020) 3 .MIST incorporates ACT principles alongside speech and stuttering modification strategies, with an emphasis on individualized treatment and shared decision-making.

These approaches illustrate the growing influence of ACT within stuttering therapy. However, they also highlight an important distinction between ACT as a psychological framework aimed at developing psychological flexibility and its application within integrated interventions that may additionally target changes in speech production or fluency.

A Critical Perspective on the Integration of ACT in Stuttering Therapy

While approaches such as fACTS and MIST represent important attempts to incorporate Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) into stuttering intervention, their integration of ACT principles also raises important theoretical questions. Rather than developing an intervention primarily from ACT’s underlying philosophical and theoretical assumptions, these approaches have incorporated ACT processes into treatment frameworks that already include speech-focused techniques and objectives. This raises the question of whether ACT has been allowed to fundamentally challenge established assumptions within stuttering therapy, or whether it has primarily been adapted to fit them. In particular, there appears to be limited critical examination of what a stuttering intervention grounded exclusively in ACT might look like, without presupposing that speech modification or increased fluency should form part of the therapeutic process. Such an approach might instead begin by examining experiential avoidance, psychological inflexibility, and the functions of speech-related behaviors, allowing therapeutic goals to emerge from the individual’s values rather than from established treatment traditions. This does not imply that speech-focused interventions are inherently incompatible with ACT. However, from a functional contextual perspective, their relevance would depend on the purposes they serve for the individual, including whether they facilitate meaningful engagement or function primarily as strategies for avoiding unwanted internal experiences. A more fundamental application of ACT to stuttering would therefore require not only integrating its techniques, but also critically examining the assumptions and therapeutic objectives into which those techniques are introduced.

The Connection Between Stoicism and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)

Although Stoicism and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) emerged in very different historical contexts, they share several important principles. In their paper Can Stoicism Inspire Stuttering Intervention?, Connery et al. (2023) 4 identify a number of Stoic practices that closely resemble processes found in ACT.

One particularly interesting connection concerns the Stoic practice of voluntary discomfort. The Stoics believed that deliberately exposing oneself to uncomfortable experiences could help cultivate courage and resilience. Rather than organizing life around avoiding discomfort, individuals were encouraged to discover that difficult experiences could be tolerated. This resembles the ACT concept of willingness, which involves being open to unwanted thoughts, emotions, and bodily sensations when doing so supports meaningful action.

For people who stutter, this might involve initiating a conversation despite anticipating stuttering, making a telephone call despite experiencing anxiety, or openly acknowledging their stuttering in a situation where they would previously have concealed it. From an ACT perspective, the purpose is not necessarily to reduce anxiety or stuttering, but to develop greater psychological flexibility by allowing uncomfortable experiences to be present while pursuing personally meaningful activities.

Another connection concerns the relationship between thoughts and reality. Epictetus emphasized the importance of examining our impressions rather than automatically accepting them as accurate representations of events. Connery et al. (2023) draw parallels between this Stoic practice and cognitive defusion in ACT. Cognitive defusion involves learning to observe thoughts as mental events rather than treating them as unquestionable truths or instructions that must be followed. For example, a person who stutters might notice the thought, “Everyone will think I am incompetent if I stutter,” without necessarily allowing that thought to determine whether they participate in a conversation.

The Stoic dichotomy of control also has important similarities with ACT. Epictetus distinguished between what depends on us and what does not, encouraging individuals to direct their efforts toward their own judgments, intentions, and actions rather than becoming preoccupied with external outcomes. Similarly, ACT emphasizes the importance of pursuing valued actions without requiring control over unwanted internal experiences. For someone who stutters, this distinction may involve recognizing that fluent speech cannot always be guaranteed, while meaningful participation and authentic communication remain possible.

Finally, both approaches emphasize the importance of practicing their principles in everyday life. Stoic exercises involving attention to one’s judgments, anticipation of adversity, and daily reflection resemble aspects of present-moment awareness and committed action in ACT.

Despite these similarities, an important distinction remains. Stoicism is a philosophy of life in which virtue and good character are central, whereas ACT is a psychological approach primarily concerned with developing psychological flexibility in the service of personally chosen values. The two approaches therefore share several practical principles without necessarily sharing the same philosophical objectives.

Taken together, these connections suggest that Stoicism and ACT offer complementary perspectives on living with stuttering. Both challenge the assumption that discomfort must be eliminated before meaningful action can take place. Instead, they invite individuals to consider whether efforts to avoid unwanted experiences are restricting their ability to participate in life as they wish.

Conclusion: Beyond Managing Discomfort

The connections between Stoicism, CBT, and ACT illustrate how ideas developed more than two thousand years ago remain relevant to contemporary psychology. As Connery et al. (2023) demonstrate, Stoic practices such as voluntary discomfort, examining one’s judgments, and distinguishing between what is and is not within our control have clear parallels in modern psychological approaches.

However, these similarities also invite us to consider the purposes for which such principles are applied. In stuttering therapy, acceptance, willingness, and exposure can easily become understood primarily as strategies for reducing anxiety, discomfort, or stuttering itself. While such changes may occur, making them the ultimate measure of success risks overlooking a more fundamental question: What kind of life does the individual wish to live?

Both Stoicism and ACT offer perspectives that extend beyond symptom reduction. Stoicism emphasizes living according to virtue, while ACT emphasizes psychological flexibility and actions guided by personally chosen values. Neither requires the elimination of discomfort as a prerequisite for meaningful living.

For people who stutter, this distinction may be particularly important. The willingness to experience stuttering, anxiety, or embarrassment need not be justified by the possibility that these experiences will eventually diminish. It may instead reflect a decision to participate in life without making participation conditional on fluent speech or emotional comfort.

Perhaps the most valuable contribution of Stoicism to contemporary stuttering therapy is therefore not another collection of techniques, but an invitation to reconsider what those techniques are ultimately intended to achieve.

Rather than asking only how we can reduce stuttering or its associated discomfort, we might also ask a different question:

How can we live well, even when stuttering and discomfort remain part of our experience?

ACT and StutterReflection

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) is one of the perspectives that has inspired the development of StutterReflection. Through daily reflections, the app invites people who stutter to explore concepts such as acceptance, experiential avoidance, psychological flexibility, and values-based action. Rather than offering techniques to control or reduce stuttering, StutterReflection encourages users to reflect on their relationship with stuttering and how they wish to navigate everyday communication. Alongside ACT, the app draws inspiration from Stoic philosophy and other perspectives that encourage self-reflection and personal growth. StutterReflection is not a therapy program, but a tool for exploring ideas that may support a more open and flexible relationship with stuttering.

  1. Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for adults who stutter: psychosocial adjustment and speech fluency – PubMed ↩︎
  2. Evaluation of an Integrated Fluency and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy Intervention for Adolescents and Adults Who Stutter | Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research ↩︎
  3. What works for whom? Multidimensional individualized stuttering therapy (MIST) – PubMed ↩︎
  4. Can Stoicism inspire stuttering intervention? The clinical usefulness of an ancient philosophy – PubMed ↩︎